I am wondering how the extractor inside the screw breech of the french field cannon operates.
1) The shell is inserted, 2) the breech chamber closed by rotating the breech block, 3) the firing hammer triggers the fuze, 4) the shell gets fired 5) the breech block is rotated back so the chamber is open again - and then? - the extractor should come in to play - throwing out the empty cartridges to the rear as can be seen in videos showing the cannon in action.. however regarding the actual extracting mechanism to me things seem less obvious.
None of the reference material would show how extactly the cartridge extractor is released. Is it pure air pressure inside the chamber that would make the extractor arms snap back? If so, how is it maintained until the moment the chamber opens again?
The picture shows the basic extractor elements: http://de.academic.ru/pictures/dewiki/55/75mm1897BreechMechanismDiagram.jpg
There is an extractor, an extractor tang, an extractor spindle and two extractor arms embracing the end of the muzzle. Is there anything that clarifies how these elements work in interaction with each other?
-- Edited by Truffi on Wednesday 19th of August 2015 02:27:56 PM
-- Edited by Truffi on Wednesday 19th of August 2015 02:28:25 PM
-- Edited by Truffi on Wednesday 19th of August 2015 02:29:48 PM
I have wondered the same thing. I am in the early stages of building a detailed 1:8 scale model of the French 75 (as I posted on this forum a few months ago.)
While my model will be as functional as I can make it. But it is not intended to be a firing cannon. Therefore, my model need not punch out an empty shell casing.
I've studied French and American drawings and visited two actual guns: a M1897A3 at Camp Roberts in April, and an actual French 1897 last month at the Orange County Court House, both in California.
The one at Camp Roberts is at a museum. Although outdoors, it is in fairly good shape. Because my project is on the original French version, the M1897A3 carriage, with its dual trail, steel wheels/rubber tires, etc was rather a disappointment after a six hour drive, not really relevant to my project. But its breech was operable. It had no firing pin, but I could operate the safety and open/close the breech, seeing the extractor arms.
The French one is in 24x7 open public display as a war memorial. As expected, its working mechanisms are immobilized. In this case, the breech is tack-welded closed. The main focus of my July visit was to study and measure the wheels and axle components, as that is the focus of my current machining and woodworking. It's just 80 miles from here, so I will be returning there for further observations. Other than the welds, some things are missing (notably the shield and sighting mechanisms.)
It doesn't show well in your image, but the extractor spindle in your diagram is an oddly curved piece. I have a French diagram that labels it "Poignée de l'axe d'extracteur", or extractor axis handle. When the breech is fully opened, I believe it depresses this handle enabling the extractor to push the shell out. But I don't see anything that would forcibly expel the shell. It seems more like some shotguns, where when you break it open, the spent shell is just lifted a little bit clear of the breech enabling you to easily grasp the brass for removal. But I have see online video of the French 75 in rapid fire action. When that breech is opened, the shell is forcibly ejected, not just lifted clear.
I don't see any spring that gets cocked to store enough energy to do this. Nor do I yet see any connection between the recoil brake and the ejector where somehow energy is absorbed during the recoil, stored while the barrel is returning to battery, then released to the ejector when the breech is opened.
Related to this, I don't understand the function and operation of that rectangular latch key on the underside of the barrel.
You are definately right, the motion of the breech block triggers it somehow, but the fact doesn't help, since the question is how it does that - meaning the mechanism behind.
In this video one can clearly see, the shell is not simply being released and dropping out, it is rather catapulted - so it must be driven by some coordinated force:
Yes I had a look at these, and it seems to be the best reference for the Schneider cannon. Here is some other related imagery, which might be helpful understanding the shell extractor:
First, concerning the mystery about the rectangular thing below the tube, maybe I can at least bring some light into the matter. This table linked below illustrates the function of it, it is labelled "Clavette" or "Coupler Key" or "Safety Bolt", if that's what you mean. As I understand it, the Clavette simply unlocks the breech block by pushing down the part highlighted in yellow:
I think the purpose of the Clavette is if the gun is abandoned, the bolt can be carried off and the gun would not be functional for the enemy or anyone unauthorized.
Concerning the extractor spindle I have a theory: while turning to opening position the breech block causes the extractor tang to be pushed into it's cavity - which makes the extractor spin rotate to a certain angle (counter-clockwise when seen from the right). The extractor arms or extractor branches then snap rearward carrying the shell, which results in the catapulting motion.
The tang can be best seen here on the lower right:
It must be quite well-coordinated mechinism since it would need to be rotated at exactly the right moment and on a high frequency without risking too much wear on the material. Another thing I find hard to grasp is how the arms return to their original position. It's either triggered by the breech block's front side at exactly the right time during the breech block's closing in order not to get squeezed by the breech block. Or it does snap back right after it has thrown out the shell.. (maybe because the tang slipped into another notch inside the front part of the breech block) Or are the arms pushed back by the insertion of a new shell?
The main problem I see with all the illustrations is that two snapped back extractor arms actually don't really seem to fit in there. There is simply no space for any movement of the extractor arms inside the hole of the muzzle breech when the breech block is in opening position. So far photos couldn't provide any clarification to the issue.. Maybe I am looking at things wrong?
So on how it really works, most certainty we have, if there is a visual reference of the extraxtor arms snapped to the rear when the spindle is rotated. A photo of the front part of the breech block or of the extractor arms in detail could also be a good basis to understand the engineering.
"23. Fonctionnement de l'extracteur. — La culasse étant
fermée, les branches de l’extracteur sont appliquées contre
le tube par le bourrelet de la douille.
Pendant l'ouverture de la culasse, la rainure du talon
d'extracteur défile devant le talon et,à la fin du mouvement,
la rampe d’éjection vient heurter la rampé hélicoïdale du
talon; ce choc entraîne le mouvement vers l'arrière de
branches de l'extracteur, ce qui produit le décollement et
l'éjection de la douille.
Lors du chargement, le Lancement de la cartouche dans
l'âme provoque le basculement vers l’avant des branches de
l'extracteur et, par suite de la réaction du talon sur la rampe
d'éjection, un commencement de fermeture de la culasse."
Google translates this as:
"23. Operation of the extractor. - The cylinder head being
closed, the arms of the extractor are applied against
the tube by the bead of the sleeve.
During the opening of the breech, the heel groove
stripper moves past the heel and at the end of the movement,
the ejection ramp strikes the worm crawled from
heel; This shock causes the backward movement of
branches of the extractor, resulting in delamination and
ejection of the sleeve (cartridge).
When charging, the launch of the cartridge in
the core causes the forward tilting of the branches of
and the extractor as a result of the reaction of the heel on the ramp
Eject a breech closure beginning."
If you look at the diagrams (lithographs) of the breech block of the Mle 1897 there are machined ramps on the inside of the block which are designated as
extractor ramps. These engage the tenon attached the extractor axle as the breech is turned. The extractor arms are forced rearwards and pull the cartridge
out of the breech. It's a fairly simple system and reminds me somewhat of the Nordenfeld breech on the earlier 6 Pounder anti-torpedo boat gun.
Thanks for these insights. Apart from the tenon ramp on the front side of the breech block, Planche 5 also shows rather large bevels, that look almost like they have been carved out or sliced off. And that explains how these long arms fit into the breech block. They are labeled "degagements et repos de la branche droite de l'extracteur" and "degagements de la branche gauche de l'extracteur". That's pretty explicit - You are right and had I looked closer, I'd have discovered them before. "Degagement" means slot and "repos" means resting state. From the latter I take that the arms idle position is tilted to the rear. So only when the breech is loaded with a shell, the extractor arms are pushed to the front into the slots alongside the muzzle - like it is said in the last paragraph of the manual text. Problem solved
-- Edited by Truffi on Thursday 20th of August 2015 05:40:33 PM
-- Edited by Truffi on Thursday 20th of August 2015 05:41:39 PM
Thanks everyone for your input. I rewatched, in a frame-by-frame mode, those videos mentioned above. In one frame, the hammer falls on the firing pin, in the next frame it is at full recoil. Return to battery takes a few frames. While it's still moving, the soldier on the right already has grabbed the handle, opened the breech, and the shell is ejected. Then, about 6 more inches of travel and finally it is at battery. (What is that soldier's role on the gun team actually called?)
It seems that we are thinking that the actual ejection is powered purely by that man's rotating the breech to the open position, at which point, the edge of the manivelle (crank) arm pushes down on the poignée de l'axe d'extracteur, aka Extractor Spindle (perhaps via the goupille de loquet (latch pin)? (See Plance IV in those French drawings.) This motion then moves the extractor arm rearwards, ejecting the shell. It doesn't seem there is enough leverage in this process to so forcibly expel the shell. But clearly, this is the mechanism that actually does the ejector, not merely tripping a trigger that releases any stored energy (e.g. spring/hydraulic/pneaumatic). I wish I could ask my grandfather (whose gun battery fired the first American shot of WW I.)
Here are a two of my photos of the M1897A3 at the Camp Roberts Museum, San Miguel, California. Unfortunately, ejector parts are missing, the left side shot fails to show the poignée de l'axe d'extracteur, aka Extractor Spindle. And the clavette is replaced by a rotten chunk of wood. And the breech open image shows the slots where the ejector axle, arms, and tang are located. I operated the breech open and closed a few times, but not while seated nor while the barrel was moving!
And from the Model 1897 at the Old Orange County Courthouse, Santa Ana, California, the left side view wheel image does show the curved Extractor Spindle arm (when you zoom in.)
Anyone want more photos? Any specific details or measurements for my next visit to Orange County?
Meanwhile, after lunch, I'm back to my workshop to work on my 1:8 scale M1897. Today, hopefully finish cutting the 14 jantes (fellows) for the wooden wheels (Planche XXIV in the French drawings), and machining the width of their cercles (tires or rims). These tires are from 14 gauge steel, I haven't yet figured exactly how I will bend and weld them. Probably will make a plain wooden disk to guide the bending of red hot strips, and a special fixture to clamp the ends together while I weld them. I haven't yet started making the spokes and the spoke shoes will be difficult to make in an efficient manner, I need 28 of them.
I would be very interested to know how you are constructing the wooden components of the wheels, and what materials you are using. I do hope that you will document your progress and let us see how it goes.
Thanks Greg for the revealing picture of the breech. I had been looking at a lot of photos, but never got to see the inner ramps on the breech block's front side.
I am sure more gaps in my reference image gallery will occur while creating my 3d model. The most critical parts are the button side of the chassis and the mechanics that control the elevation of the gun's barrel, located between barrel and chassis.
There is no real-life example near to where I live, so any detailed images you can upload would make me happy.
Michael, Truffi, and the gang,
Glad to help on this and I will certainly 1) post more of my photos from the Camp Roberts and Orange County Courthouse guns. Does this forum have some standard or preferred "style" of doing so?
And I will begin posting progress reports with photos on my build. I suppose the thread should be in the Modelling folder, rather than Artillery? Mine seems to be a much larger scale (1:8) project than most of the other threads.
Note that I am already reporting on this on the Hobby Machinist website: www.hobby-machinist.com/threads/gregs-french-75-mm-field-artillery-model.34665/ and occasionally on Facebook to keep my friends and family apprised of my activity. I think the Home Machinist group is rather more focused on the machines and tools than the projects themselves. So this Landships gang may well better appreciate and advise on my work.